SEARCH
« DOJ Launches Group to Combat Oil, Gas Fraud | Main | Colorado Boy, 8, Sues over Drunk-Driving Crash that Killed His Mom »
Thursday
Apr212011

Michigan Police Use Device to Download Cellphone Data; ACLU Objects

Cellbrite(LANSING, Mich.) -- A high-tech gadget that can quickly download information from a cellphone is at the center of a controversy that's pitting civil liberties advocates against state police in Michigan.

Since 2008, the ACLU of Michigan has been petitioning the Michigan State Police to turn over information about their use of so-called "data extraction devices" (or DEDs). Manufactured by Cellebrite, a mobile forensics and data services company headquartered in Israel, the devices can connect to cellphones and, even bypassing passwords, retrieve phone numbers, text messages, call history, photos and video.

The issue came to a head this week, after the ACLU published a letter it sent to the state police, demanding transparency and saying misuse of the device could be a Fourth Amendment violation. Michigan State Police issued a statement Wednesday, claiming that "it only uses the DEDs if a search warrant is obtained or if the person possessing the mobile device gives consent."

But civil liberties advocates say that law enforcement's response is insufficient.

"They don't say anything about their past behavior. It's a carefully crafted statement," said Kary Moss, executive director of the ACLU of Michigan.

On a "tip" that police had used a DED unlawfully, Moss said the ACLU filed its first Freedom of Information Act (FOIA) request in 2008 to learn the policies and practices surrounding the extraction device, but the police did not offer answers. Instead, they told the ACLU it would need to pay more than $544,000 to retrieve the records and reports it had asked for. Over the past few years, Moss said the ACLU has tried to work with the police to narrow the request and lower the cost, but with little success.

"We have credible information that they were being used during routine stops without a warrant," she said. "And their response that information would cost half a million dollars suggests that there was some widespread use."

But Michigan State Police spokeswoman Tiffany Brown said the devices have never been used to take personal cellphone information from citizens during routine stops.

Since the state got roughly six DEDs in 2006, Brown said, they have been used by specialty teams in high-level cases that require digital forensics methods -- for example, a child pornography case in which officers would need data from a suspect's computer and cellphone.

When asked why the cost of meeting the ACLU's FOIA requests were in six digits, Brown said that was what it would cost to have several employees, working full-time, assemble documents from a five-year period. She also said that in the five years that the state has owned the extraction devices, it has not received any citizen complaints or been named in any lawsuits.

Copyright 2011 ABC News Radio´╗┐

References (47)

References allow you to track sources for this article, as well as articles that were written in response to this article.
  • Response
    Michigan Police Use Device to Download Cellphone Data; ACLU Objects - National News - ABC News Radio
  • Response
    Michigan Police Use Device to Download Cellphone Data; ACLU Objects - National News - ABC News Radio
  • Response
    Response: why not try it
    Michigan Police Use Device to Download Cellphone Data; ACLU Objects - National News - ABC News Radio
  • Response
    Response: this page
    Michigan Police Use Device to Download Cellphone Data; ACLU Objects - National News - ABC News Radio
  • Response
    Michigan Police Use Device to Download Cellphone Data; ACLU Objects - National News - ABC News Radio
  • Response
    Michigan Police Use Device to Download Cellphone Data; ACLU Objects - National News - ABC News Radio
  • Response
    Response: try here
    Michigan Police Use Device to Download Cellphone Data; ACLU Objects - National News - ABC News Radio
  • Response
    Michigan Police Use Device to Download Cellphone Data; ACLU Objects - National News - ABC News Radio
  • Response
    Response: triciawang.com
    Michigan Police Use Device to Download Cellphone Data; ACLU Objects - National News - ABC News Radio
  • Response
    Michigan Police Use Device to Download Cellphone Data; ACLU Objects - National News - ABC News Radio
  • Response
    Michigan Police Use Device to Download Cellphone Data; ACLU Objects - National News - ABC News Radio
  • Response
    Michigan Police Use Device to Download Cellphone Data; ACLU Objects - National News - ABC News Radio
  • Response
    Response: comment-7991
    Michigan Police Use Device to Download Cellphone Data; ACLU Objects - National News - ABC News Radio
  • Response
    Response: on yahoo
    Michigan Police Use Device to Download Cellphone Data; ACLU Objects - National News - ABC News Radio
  • Response
    Michigan Police Use Device to Download Cellphone Data; ACLU Objects - National News - ABC News Radio
  • Response
    Michigan Police Use Device to Download Cellphone Data; ACLU Objects - National News - ABC News Radio
  • Response
    Michigan Police Use Device to Download Cellphone Data; ACLU Objects - National News - ABC News Radio
  • Response
    Michigan Police Use Device to Download Cellphone Data; ACLU Objects - National News - ABC News Radio
  • Response
    Response: insanity dvd uk
    Michigan Police Use Device to Download Cellphone Data; ACLU Objects - National News - ABC News Radio
  • Response
    Response: official website
    Michigan Police Use Device to Download Cellphone Data; ACLU Objects - National News - ABC News Radio
  • Response
    Response: look at here
    Michigan Police Use Device to Download Cellphone Data; ACLU Objects - National News - ABC News Radio
  • Response
    Michigan Police Use Device to Download Cellphone Data; ACLU Objects - National News - ABC News Radio
  • Response
    Response: suffolkdeaf.co.uk
    Michigan Police Use Device to Download Cellphone Data; ACLU Objects - National News - ABC News Radio
  • Response
    Response: check my site
    Michigan Police Use Device to Download Cellphone Data; ACLU Objects - National News - ABC News Radio
  • Response
    Response: yonsei.ac.kr
    Michigan Police Use Device to Download Cellphone Data; ACLU Objects - National News - ABC News Radio
  • Response
    Michigan Police Use Device to Download Cellphone Data; ACLU Objects - National News - ABC News Radio
  • Response
    Response: their explanation
    Michigan Police Use Device to Download Cellphone Data; ACLU Objects - National News - ABC News Radio
  • Response
    Michigan Police Use Device to Download Cellphone Data; ACLU Objects - National News - ABC News Radio
  • Response
    Response: miwiki.net
    Michigan Police Use Device to Download Cellphone Data; ACLU Objects - National News - ABC News Radio
  • Response
    National News and Headlines From ABC News Radio
  • Response
    The idea of the electronic gadgets goes far beyond that and requires the variety of devices that impacts the life of typical folks.
  • Response
    Response: shoes for women
    Michigan Police Use Device to Download Cellphone Data; ACLU Objects - National News - ABC News Radio
  • Response
    Michigan Police Use Device to Download Cellphone Data; ACLU Objects - National News - ABC News Radio
  • Response
    Response: kbminjoo.kr
    Michigan Police Use Device to Download Cellphone Data; ACLU Objects - National News - ABC News Radio
  • Response
    Michigan Police Use Device to Download Cellphone Data; ACLU Objects - National News - ABC News Radio
  • Response
    Michigan Police Use Device to Download Cellphone Data; ACLU Objects - National News - ABC News Radio
  • Response
    Response: weddingpedia.pl
    Michigan Police Use Device to Download Cellphone Data; ACLU Objects - National News - ABC News Radio
  • Response
    Michigan Police Use Device to Download Cellphone Data; ACLU Objects - National News - ABC News Radio
  • Response
    Michigan Police Use Device to Download Cellphone Data; ACLU Objects - National News - ABC News Radio
  • Response
    Michigan Police Use Device to Download Cellphone Data; ACLU Objects - National News - ABC News Radio
  • Response
    Michigan Police Use Device to Download Cellphone Data; ACLU Objects - National News - ABC News Radio
  • Response
    Michigan Police Use Device to Download Cellphone Data; ACLU Objects - National News - ABC News Radio
  • Response
    Michigan Police Use Device to Download Cellphone Data; ACLU Objects - National News - ABC News Radio
  • Response
    Michigan Police Use Device to Download Cellphone Data; ACLU Objects - National News - ABC News Radio
  • Response
    Michigan Police Use Device to Download Cellphone Data; ACLU
  • Response
    Michigan Police Use Device to Download Cellphone Data; ACLU
  • Response
    Michigan Police Use Device to Download Cellphone Data; ACLU

Reader Comments

There are no comments for this journal entry. To create a new comment, use the form below.

PostPost a New Comment

Enter your information below to add a new comment.

My response is on my own website »
Author Email (optional):
Author URL (optional):
Post:
 
Some HTML allowed: <a href="" title=""> <abbr title=""> <acronym title=""> <b> <blockquote cite=""> <code> <em> <i> <strike> <strong>






ABC News Radio